Striking It Rich in Ancient Times: An Example From the Song Dynasty

In “Notes on the Dynamics of Human Civilization: the Growth Revolution” and “A Flawed Comparison: Inequality, Ancient and Modern” I contended that the process through which premodern societies and individuals acquired their riches is fundamentally different from the way fortunes are created and acquired today. An interesting example is provided by the Song Dynasty and […]

Continue Reading

Notes From All Over (14/4/2013) – Digital Feudalism, Macrohistory, and Energy

A collection of articles, essays, and blog post of merit. This collection is a large one.  TOP BILLING Our Internet Surveillance StateBruce Schneier. Schneier on Security. 25 March 2013. The Internet is a surveillance state. Whether we admit it to ourselves or not, and whether we like it or not, we’re being tracked all the […]

Continue Reading

“Winning Hearts and Minds” Is Dead

“The primary objective of any COIN operation is to foster development of effective governance by a legitimate government. Counterinsurgents achieve this objective by the balanced application of both military and nonmilitary means…. Governments described as β€œlegitimate” rule primarily with the consent of the governed; those described as β€œillegitimate” tend to rely mainly or entirely on […]

Continue Reading

Far Right and Far Left – Two Peas in a Pod?

Infographic from Ty Morteson. Image Source.One might add “Governments consistently bails out corporate interests with tax-payer money” to the center of the diagram. Several months ago I published a post that describes how the extreme partisanship emanating from Washington is a really just a surface veneer that covers a plutocratic consensus lying beneath. [1] Ashwin Parameswaran, blogging […]

Continue Reading

Whence Springs a Strategic Canon?

Scrolls containing the Seven Military Classics of the Chinese strategic canon. Image Credit.  Last month I wrote a post on the difficulties Westerners face learning about China’s military history and expansive strategic canon. Reflecting on this military tradition, Martin Hewson (who blogs at Breviosity) posed a few interesting questions: Why does China have such a sophisticated tradition […]

Continue Reading

Testing Your Knowledge of Indian Politics

How well do you know Indian politics? High school history text books often include political cartoons students must interpret to demonstrate their understanding of the period in question. When I saw the following political cartoon, published in Outlook India earlier this week, it occurred to me that modern political cartoons can be just as useful a test. Krish […]

Continue Reading

March Round-Up

Β©Dave Walker, image from weblogcartoons.com After a two year hiatus the Scholar’s Stage opened up its doors to discussion once again.  All significant essays published since the re-boot began in February are posted below. I thank all of the readers and commentators that make posting here a rewarding experience. THE REPUBLIC Ominous Parallels: What Antebellum America […]

Continue Reading

West and East and How We Think

What impact does culture have on cognition? Psychologist Richard Nisbett has conducted dozens of studies to find out the answer to this question. Presented in The Geography of Thought: How Asians and Westerners Think Differently, the results of his study are fascinating – and their implications far reaching. “Perception: How Germans and Chinese See Each Other” from […]

Continue Reading